Navigating the complex alliances of 9th-century England in Assassin's Creed Valhalla often forces players to act as detectives alongside their duties as conquerors. During the Essexe story arc, Eivor is tasked with identifying a traitor in the Old Wounds quest line to protect Rollo and his camp. Uncovering the truth requires evaluating conflicting testimonies and analyzing environmental clues.

The Suspects in the Old Wounds Quest

When Eivor arrives at Rollo's camp after a sudden Saxon attack, two primary suspects emerge: Gerhild and Lork. Both individuals claim they were away hunting rabbits during the assault to explain their absence. However, speaking to them reveals immediate inconsistencies in their stories.

Gerhild expresses clear resentment toward Rollo's leadership and his involvement with Estrid. Lork, an older warrior bound by a blood oath, appears weary and fragile.

Evaluating the Clues and Evidence

Investigating the camp provides crucial context that disproves the initial statements. Using Odin's Sight reveals a hunting rack fully stocked with meat, proving neither had a reason to hunt. Additionally, a hidden spot in the tall grass near the camp suggests someone was hiding during the ambush.

When re-interrogated, Lork admits he was sleeping in the woods and hid when the Saxons arrived. Gerhild alters her story to claim she was meeting a Saxon lover, which Lork witnessed.

Who Betrayed Rollo?

The true traitor who betrayed Rollo is Gerhild. Her claim of meeting a Saxon lover is a cover for conspiring directly with the enemy forces. Given her vocal disdain for Saxons and her jealousy toward Rollo's alliance with Estrid, her excuse crumbles under scrutiny.

Lork's blood oath and physical weakness align with his explanation of hiding out of self-preservation. Identifying Gerhild ensures justice is served and protects the camp from further deceit.

Consequences of Your Choice

Accusing Gerhild results in her immediate execution, securing Rollo's camp and streamlining the remaining missions in Essexe. Choosing the correct suspect prevents future interference during Estrid's planned departure.

If you mistakenly accuse Lork, Gerhild remains free and causes complications later in the story arc. She will directly attempt to harm Estrid, making the escape plan far more difficult to execute.